Chapter Four
As you can imagine, my hand immediately shot into the air. No, not really. It was kind of the opposite actually. Liz ended up being the first to volunteer, but even she was a bit reluctant. After Mandi shut the door on her, I could literally hear my own heart beating. She was in there for about 5 minutes before she came out with a nervous smile on her face and said, “No Mary.”
Katie and Becca pretty much had the same response after they came out. Then Mandi looked at me. “Well,” she said, “are you going or not?” Then Jessica rolled her eyes, looked at me, and said, “You don’t have to do this. I haven’t even decided if I’m going to. Obviously it doesn’t even work.” After she said this, Mandi looked like she was about to bite off her own tongue.
“You’re not going to do it? That’s the whole point of this party! You’ll have to leave if you refuse. It’s just not fair to my other guests.” With this, Jessica stood up, but I wasn’t about to stay here without her. “Wait Jess! If I go in…will you?” She waited a minute, looked at me, and said, “Sure…why not.” Mandi smiled as I rose from my spot on the floor.
“Just say her name 3 times…it’s easy,” Liz whispered to me as I slipped into the bathroom. And right before she shut me in, Mandi whispered, “Just remember to shut your eyes after the final spin. If you see her, you die.” Then…darkness.
Well, that was comforting. I grabbed the matches I saw by the sink and started to light the candles that surrounded the mirror. I looked up and saw exactly what I had expected to see: my own reflection staring back at me. No one else. Okay, I thought, turn 3 times while saying the name. In the words of Professor Cadenza, this is bullshit. So why am I shaking?
I raised my gaze back to my reflection. “Bloody Mary.” I spun once, slowly, trying to get the feel of it. “Bloody Mary.” The second time I spun, I realized what an idiot I must look like. I wondered if the other girls actually did this or if they faked it. “Bloody Mary.” I was reluctant to spin the final time, so I did it quickly and forced myself to look in the mirror. Nothing. Just my own frightened reflection anticipating something that wasn’t real. And then, the candles blew out. Oh…my…God…
Well, I screamed bloody murder and the door opened to a very smug-looking Mandi. “What happened?” She asked in a mocking tone, “Did you see your reflection?” Katie snickered and then Becca punched her arm. I like Becca. I just ignored Mandi and went to sit between Jessica and Liz. “The candles went out,” I whispered to Jessica, “tell me that’s not creepy.”
“Well maybe you spun really fast the 3rd time…” Jessica suggested, but when she saw the look on my face she said, “You’re right though, that is really creepy.”
“Hmm…well since Jessica doesn’t want to go in then I guess I’ll go next…” Mandi gave Jessica her most beautiful (cruel) smile. And of course, Jessica couldn’t resist. “Quit being such a bitch Mandi. I said I’d do it if Anna did, didn’t I? I’m true to my word.” And with that, Jessica stalked into the bathroom and shut the door. I felt proud to call myself her roommate. Mandi didn’t respond to the bitch comment, but then again, Jessica didn’t really give her a chance.
Liz turned to me and asked, “So…did you see her?” I knew who she was talking about, though I didn’t really know how I should answer her question. I didn’t know if she was being serious or not. So instead of giving her a response, I asked, “Who?”
“Mary!” Liz whispered, looking strangely flushed. She looked at me with anticipation. “Why,” I asked, “did you see her?” Now it was Liz’s turn to look like she didn’t know how to answer. She’s got to be kidding. However, before I could say anything, we heard a blood-curdling scream come from the bathroom.
“Sounds like your roommate gets scared easily too, Anna.” Mandi sneered. However, this scream didn’t sound anything like my scream. It sounded like…like a strangled cry or…something…
“Jessica?” I said as I cautiously made my way to the bathroom door. “She always got scared easily at camp when we were younger,” Liz said. “Or…wait…maybe that was Sami…” I stopped looking at Liz and got closer to the door separating Jessica and me. “Jessica?” I called a little louder, my voice cracking a bit. I put my hand on the doorknob, pressed my ear against the wood, and listened for a moment. No sound came from inside. I had a sick feeling in the pit of my stomach…and my ears were stinging.
“She probably fainted!” Katie squealed and then Becca punched her arm again. I opened the door a crack and said her name softly, “Jessica?” And then…blackness.
***
The first thing I saw when I awoke was a blinding red light. Then the red turned to blue. It took me a minute for my mind to register where I was. A man in a black uniform was staring at me; he was a cop. Next to him stood a paramedic. I was lying down on a bed inside an ambulance. I bolted upright…that was a mistake. A stabbing pain forced its way into my skull that made me shudder. As soon as I started to moan, I heard a deep voice to my right.
“Well that was stupid.” Johnny was leaning over me. “Wha…what happened? When did I hit my head?” Johnny’s first expression was one of confusion, and then that morphed into complete sadness. “I don’t really know if I can answer…” he started, but he was then interrupted by the cop on my left.
“What do you remember about tonight Miss Kirby?” His tone was threatening and interrogative. I started to sit up. “Careful! Come up slowly now.” This came from the paramedic leaning over me. I could tell from the sour expression on her face that she was annoyed with the officer standing next to her for questioning me while she was in the middle of her examination of my head. Although, refusing to lay down when I most likely have a concussion probably didn’t make her happy either. I decided to do what she said and come up with caution.
“Umm well…I was at a sleepover and…wait…what? How did I get here from…?” I stuttered and when I looked up I saw Katie and Becca. Katie was shaking while Becca just stared off into oblivion. Mandi and Liz were right next to them. Mandi was pacing nervously and wringing her fingers, but Liz…Liz was sobbing violently. She was planted on the ground, rocking back and forth, trying very hard to breathe steadily. There was an older woman holding her and trying to comfort her….maybe her mom.
“From where Miss Kirby? What do you remember about the sleepover you were at tonight?” The officer’s voice sounded like a faraway echo. There was only one person on my mind. And suddenly, I did remember the last place I was before I woke up in this parking lot…and I ran to it. Ignoring the cops making a grab for me, the paramedic’s and Johnny’s cries for me to come back, the hysterical people crowded around the building, and the stabbing pain that felt like it was cutting my head open, I broke open the doors and sprinted up the stairs to the 3rd floor. I was at Mandi and Liz’s door in about 30 seconds. Tearing through the yellow caution tape, I made my way to the bathroom. I came across the same sight I found before I blacked out 3 hours earlier (I later found out). There, sprawled across the bathroom floor, lay a cold and lifeless Jessica.
Her once dark, shimmering skin was now pale and clammy. The mouth that used to welcome me with a kind and loving smile whenever I saw her was now frozen in the shape of an oval. Those beautiful dark eyes that lit up whenever I saw her were now in a fixed gaze, paralyzed with fear. Jessica had been sliced open in a vertical line starting from her chin to her navel. The once pearly white bathroom was now covered from ceiling to floor in crimson.
I wasn’t standing there long before the police on the scene grabbed me and dragged me outside. As soon as my gaze was forcibly ripped from Jessica’s horrified face, I seemed to come back to reality. Once I was in the hallway, I dropped to my knees and vomited.